Negotiation Strategies & Contract Terms for Buying S/4HANA Licenses

Negotiation Strategies & Contract Terms for Buying S/4HANA Licenses

Why Negotiating S/4HANA Licensing is Critical: SAP’s sticker prices for S/4HANA are rarely the prices you actually have to pay.

Treat SAP’s list price as a starting point – not the final word. A well-negotiated deal can significantly lower your upfront costs and long-term maintenance expenses.

Given the complexity of SAP licensing and the current push to move customers onto S/4HANA, buyers have more leverage than ever to demand better terms.

SAP’s drive to migrate its customer base from ECC to S/4HANA (ahead of the 2027 support deadline) creates a strategic opening for customers. SAP wants your business on S/4HANA, so they’re often willing to grant concessions on price and contract terms to secure your commitment.

Enterprises that negotiate these deals strategically save millions over the lifetime of their SAP investment – not just in lower license fees, but through reduced annual costs and avoided compliance penalties.

In short, approaching S/4HANA licensing with a negotiation mindset is essential to protect your budget and business interests. Read our S/4HANA Licensing 2025 – The Executive Playbook.

Negotiation Leverage in S/4HANA Licensing

Understanding your leverage points is key to driving a favorable S/4HANA deal. Use every advantage at your disposal to push SAP for better pricing and terms.

Some proven ways to maximize your leverage include:

• Bring Competitive Alternatives to the Table: Even if you intend to go with S/4HANA, make it clear that you have other options. Mentioning credible alternatives (Oracle Cloud ERP, Workday, Salesforce, Microsoft Dynamics, etc.) puts pressure on SAP. The possibility that you could invest elsewhere motivates SAP’s team to sharpen its pencil on pricing. For example, if SAP knows you’re evaluating Oracle or another ERP, they’ll be more inclined to offer steeper discounts or extra incentives to close the deal.
• Bundle Your Negotiations: Scope your negotiation broadly to include related SAP spend – such as database licenses, cloud services, or maintenance renewals – rather than negotiating S/4HANA in isolation. By bundling multiple elements (e.g., an S/4HANA license purchase with a multi-year maintenance agreement or additional SAP cloud products), you increase the deal size and your importance to SAP. In return, SAP will often extend bigger discounts or favorable terms across the bundle to secure the larger commitment. Bundling also lets you trade concessions: for instance, committing to maintain an older SAP product for a few more years in exchange for a better price on S/4HANA.
• Leverage Timing and Deadlines: Timing can be your friend. SAP’s sales representatives are under intense pressure to hit quarterly and year-end targets. Use this to your advantage by negotiating near SAP’s fiscal quarter-end or year-end. As the deadline approaches, you may see SAP suddenly improve the offer by an additional 5–15% or include extra perks that weren’t on the table earlier. Aligning your deal decision with these critical dates gives you maximum leverage – SAP will be far more flexible in Q4 when every deal helps them meet their quota. Additionally, keep renewal deadlines in mind: if your current SAP contracts or support agreements are up for renewal, that’s a prime moment to negotiate S/4HANA as part of the renewal package (or to use the threat of non-renewal to get a better S/4 offer).
• Take Advantage of SAP’s S/4HANA Push: SAP is highly motivated to showcase successful S/4HANA adoptions. They are offering incentives to move customers off legacy ECC systems. Use this knowledge. Let SAP know that your move to S/4HANA is contingent on getting a competitive, benchmark-aligned deal. Emphasize that you’re aware that other enterprises received significant discounts. SAP often prefers to win a long-term S/4HANA customer (and a reference case) at a discount rather than lose the opportunity. Your willingness to serve as a success story or to accelerate migration can become bargaining leverage for better pricing and contract flexibility.

Key Contract Terms in SAP License Agreements

When crafting your S/4HANA license agreement, pay close attention to the contract clauses. SAP’s standard contract terms often favor the vendor – and if left unchallenged, they can create costly risks for you down the road.

Smart buyers scrutinize and negotiate specific language changes to protect their interests. Focus on the following key contract areas:

• Audit Rights and Scope: SAP’s default audit clause gives them broad rights to audit your software usage at almost any time, often with minimal notice. This can lead to surprise compliance findings and disruptive audits on SAP’s schedule. Negotiate this clause to limit SAP’s audit frequency (e.g., no more than once per year) and require reasonable advance notice (like 60–90 days). Define the scope of audits so that SAP can only audit relevant systems/products rather than your entire IT landscape. Tightening audit terms ensures an invasive audit or massive back-charges won’t blindside you without the chance to prepare or remediate.
• Digital Access (Indirect Use): “Indirect” or digital access is a notorious gray area in SAP licensing. By default, SAP’s definitions are expansive – if a third-party system or external user connects to SAP data (even without a named SAP login), SAP may consider it licensable usage. This puts you at very high risk of unbudgeted license fees if, say, your Salesforce, e-commerce platform, or a supplier portal touches SAP data. To protect yourself, clarify and cap digital access costs in the contract. You might negotiate a switch to SAP’s Digital Access Document model with a fixed number of documents (or a flat fee) to cover indirect usage, or explicitly exclude certain integration scenarios from requiring extra licenses. The goal is to ensure you won’t face a multi-million dollar surprise later due to normal API integrations or data sharing with SAP.
• Shelfware and License Swaps: Many SAP customers end up with “shelfware” – unused licenses that sit idle while still incurring annual maintenance fees. SAP’s standard terms offer no relief for shelfware; once you buy licenses, you’re generally stuck with them (and their upkeep costs). This is a hidden medium-level risk that accumulates over time as your business changes. Negotiate shelfware protections such as a license swap clause or give-back credits. A license swap clause lets you exchange unused SAP licenses for other licenses of equal value as your needs evolve. For example, if you over-licensed a CRM module or have ECC licenses you no longer need post-migration, a swap right would allow you to apply that value toward new S/4HANA modules or users instead of wasting it. Securing these terms means you won’t pay forever for software you’re not using – you preserve the value of your investment by reallocating it to where you do need it.
• Termination & Migration Flexibility: Pay close attention to how you can exit or adjust the agreement. Under SAP’s default contract, termination rights are very restrictive – especially for cloud subscriptions (SAP typically only allows termination “for cause,” not for convenience). You don’t want to be locked into a multi-year deal with no escape if business conditions change or if S/4HANA isn’t meeting expectations. Negotiate flexibility for migration and exit. For on-premise licenses, ensure you can terminate unused licenses or drop maintenance on them without penalty (perhaps at yearly intervals). For cloud contracts, try to include provisions for early termination triggers (for example, allowing you to exit after year 2 of a 3-year deal if certain performance metrics aren’t met or if your company undergoes a major change). At a minimum, negotiate the right to downsize at renewal or to convert unused on-prem licenses into cloud subscriptions if you transition to SaaS. Also, clarify what happens if you stop using SAP: an ideal contract will explicitly state that on-premises S/4HANA licenses remain yours to use perpetually (even if you leave SAP support), and for cloud, it should spell out data retrieval rights and any refunds for prepaid fees. The more flexible and clear your termination/migration clauses, the less risk of being stuck paying for software that no longer aligns with your business needs.

For more insights, S/4HANA Conversion Paths: Product Conversion, Contract Conversion & Compatibility Packs.

SAP Contract Clauses to Watch:

The table below summarizes a few critical clauses, SAP’s typical stance, the risk to you as the buyer, and what you should negotiate instead:

Cost Negotiation in SAP S/4HANA

Beyond contract terms, cost is the other half of the equation. SAP’s pricing is famously opaque, so come prepared to negotiate on multiple cost fronts:

• Aim for Deep Discounts off List Prices: Never accept SAP’s list price for S/4HANA licenses – significant discounts are the norm. For a large S/4HANA deal, benchmark at least 20–40% below list as a starting target, and more if you have strong leverage. In practice, many enterprises achieve even larger discounts (50% or greater for major global deals) by playing vendors against each other and negotiating at year-end. Remember, every percentage point off list price is money saved upfront and every year on maintenance. Double-check pricing against industry benchmarks: if similar companies are paying 50% of list and you’re only getting 25% off, you know to push much harder. Conversely, if SAP offers an unusually steep discount, look for trade-offs (are they tying it to a larger bundle or stricter terms elsewhere?). The key is to drive the price down to a level that makes sense for your budget and ROI – SAP’s initial quote is just a starting bid.
• Cap Maintenance Fee Increases: SAP typically charges ~22% of your net license price per year for support. That means if you negotiate the license price down, your maintenance base also drops (a critical ongoing savings). However, you also need to protect against maintenance inflation. Many SAP contracts allow annual support fee uplifts (for example, CPI + 3% or a fixed 5% increase each year). Over a 5- or 7-year period, these increases snowball and can erode your negotiated savings. Always negotiate a cap on maintenance (support) increases. For instance, insist on something like “maintenance fees shall not increase by more than 3% per year” (or even a flat freeze for a couple of years).In some cases, you can negotiate multi-year maintenance locks – no increase for the first 2–3 years of the contract. The goal is to ensure your ongoing costs remain predictable and don’t spiral upwards unrestrained. If you’re moving to a subscription model (e.g.,
  S/4HANA Cloud or RISE with SAP, apply the same principle to your subscription renewal rate: lock in renewal pricing or put a cap on how much it can go up. Never rely on verbal promises that “we usually only raise by a small percent” – get the cap in writing in the contract.
• Negotiate Migration Incentives: If you are an existing SAP ECC customer migrating to S/4HANA, you have a unique bargaining chip. SAP wants its install base to transition, and they have offered various conversion programs and incentives. Don’t be shy about asking for migration credits. This can take different forms: credit for the residual value of your existing licenses, a discounted conversion ratio (e.g. each old ERP user license gives you a certain credit towards S/4HANA licenses), or waived fees for overlapping use during the migration period. The objective is to avoid paying twice for the same functionality. For example, if you’ve already invested millions in SAP Business Suite licenses and maintenance, negotiate that those investments count toward your S/4HANA purchase. You might secure a clause like “the value of unused ECC licenses will be applied as a discount to new S/4HANA license fees.” Additionally, seek free or discounted training, migration tools, or consulting hours as part of the deal – SAP often will throw in such extras to sweeten a migration agreement. These incentives reduce the overall cost of moving to S/4 and show SAP is sharing in the investment of your transition.

Read about Audit Risks, Compliance & Costs in S/4HANA Licensing.

Benchmarking S/4HANA Pricing

Going into negotiations, it’s crucial to ground your expectations in reality. Benchmarking S/4HANA pricing against the market ensures you know what a fair deal looks like.

SAP sales reps might claim your price is “special” or “the best we can do,” but with solid data, you can challenge those assertions.

Here’s how to use benchmarking to your advantage:

• Leverage Third-Party Data: Tap into independent benchmarks from peer companies, industry groups, or third-party advisors who specialize in SAP deal consulting. These sources can provide anonymized data on typical discounts, per-user costs, or total cost of ownership for S/4HANA in environments similar to yours. For instance, you might learn that companies of your size/industry received a 50% discount on similar S/4HANA packages. Having that insight arms you with a credible case: “Our target pricing is X, because we know of similar deals in the market.” SAP is far less likely to overcharge an informed customer.
• Compare Apples to Apples: Ensure you’re comparing deals on equivalent terms. Benchmarks vary by industry, region, and scope – a manufacturing firm buying 10,000 S/4HANA user licenses will see different pricing than a mid-size professional services firm buying 300 licenses. So gather benchmarks that reflect your scenario (user count, modules licensed, cloud vs on-prem, etc.). Use those to set an anchor in your negotiations. For example, if the average per-user price in the cloud is $100/month and SAP quotes you $140, you have room to push down. On the other hand, if you’re offered a deal that is in the top percentile of favorability, you can negotiate other terms with confidence, knowing the price is solid. The goal is to make SAP justify any quote that falls outside the normal range and to refuse any deal that doesn’t at least match what your peers are paying.
• Keep SAP Honest with Data: When you present benchmark information, do it in a firm but collaborative way. Let SAP know you’ve done your homework: “We’ve seen enterprises our size getting roughly 30-40% off – we need to be in that ballpark.” By citing external data, you shift the conversation from subjective to objective. It signals that you won’t accept an inflated price out of ignorance. Often, just demonstrating that you have benchmark intelligence will prompt SAP to improve its offer to avoid looking unreasonable. It also helps you internally – you can justify the negotiated outcome to your CFO or board by saying, “We achieved a discount in line with industry benchmarks,” or identify if you fell short. In summary, benchmarking is your reality check and your shield against overpaying. Use it to guide your target pricing and to hold SAP accountable during the deal-making process.

Advanced Negotiation Tactics

When standard negotiation steps aren’t enough, get creative with advanced tactics. As a savvy CIO or procurement leader, you can structure your deal and negotiation process in ways that extract even more value.

Consider these tactics as you refine your S/4HANA negotiation strategy:

• Stage and Phase Your Commitments: Just because you plan a multi-year S/4HANA rollout doesn’t mean you have to sign everything in one go without conditions. One tactic is to stage your purchases – commit to a larger volume or additional modules over time, rather than all at once, in exchange for guaranteed discounts now. For example, you might agree to purchase 5,000 S/4HANA user licenses, but with a deployment in phases (2,500 this year, 2,500 next year) and payment tied to those phases. This shows SAP you’re all-in on S/4HANA (helping you get a better volume discount), but protects you from paying for all users or maintenance before they’re actually needed. Another angle is to include growth or expansion clauses: lock in today’s pricing for future licenses you’ll buy later. That way, as you roll out S/4HANA to more divisions or regions, you’re not paying higher prices down the road. Staging your commitment can satisfy SAP’s desire for a big deal on paper, while aligning cash outlay with your deployment schedule.
• Secure Migration and Swap Credits: As mentioned, don’t leave the value of your existing SAP investments on the table. An advanced move is to formally negotiate license swap provisions as part of your S/4HANA deal. This goes beyond general migration credits – it means writing into the contract the right to swap or convert specific licenses. For instance, if you still have 1,000 SAP ECC Professional User licenses, you negotiate a clause that allows you to convert those to S/4HANA licenses at no additional cost when you migrate those users. Or if you purchase S/4HANA and later decide to move to the cloud version, you negotiate upfront that you can apply your on-premise license value towards a RISE with SAP subscription. By anticipating future changes (cloud adoption, module changes, company acquisitions/divestitures) and locking in swap rights now, you avoid hard conversations (and extra costs) later. Essentially, you’re future-proofing your SAP contract – ensuring it can flex with your strategy. SAP won’t volunteer these rights, but if you make it a condition (“We will sign this big S/4 deal only if we can reallocate unused licenses in the future”), you can often get at least some flexibility granted.
• Escalate and Engage Executives: Front-line SAP sales teams have their limits – if you’re not getting the concessions you need, don’t hesitate to escalate the negotiation to higher levels. This can mean involving an executive sponsor at SAP (such as a regional VP or even an executive from SAP’s head office) who has authority to approve special discounts or contract terms. Often, bringing your own C-suite into the discussion (your CIO, CFO, or even CEO for a major deal) to meet with SAP executives can break logjams. High-level conversations reinforce the importance of this deal to both sides and can unlock final concessions on price or terms that a sales representative alone might not grant. For example, a CEO-to-CEO call or a meeting between your CFO and SAP’s sales leader might yield an extra discount tier, extended payment terms, or a customized contract rider to address your concerns. Use executive relationships strategically – you don’t want to pull them in for minor issues, but for multi-million dollar agreements, it’s often appropriate. Also, if you’re a major SAP customer, remind SAP of your long-term partnership and future opportunities; a bit of goodwill and strategic partnership talk at the executive level can translate into tangible savings now. In essence, don’t keep the negotiation siloed at the procurement level if it stalls – leverage your leadership and SAP’s hierarchy to close the deal on the best possible terms.

Checklist – Preparing for S/4HANA License Negotiation

Before you sit down at the negotiating table, make sure you and your team are fully prepared.

Use the following checklist to cover all the bases in your S/4HANA license negotiation:

• ✅ Define Your Requirements and Volumes: Clearly document what S/4HANA components your business actually needs. Determine the number of users (by type), modules, and add-ons required for your S/4HANA implementation. Having a detailed bill of needs prevents overbuying and provides a firm basis for pricing discussions. Know your scope going in.
• ✅ Strengthen Your BATNA (Best Alternative): Identify and evaluate credible alternative solutions in case the SAP deal doesn’t meet your expectations. Whether it’s Oracle ERP, another platform, or delaying the project, having an alternative course empowers you in negotiations. Even internally, be clear on your walk-away option if SAP won’t bend – it will make your stance more confident.
• ✅ Gather Pricing Benchmarks: Collect data on what other companies are paying for S/4HANA. Reach out to industry peers (discreetly), consult advisors, or use market research to benchmark license costs and discounts. Enter negotiations armed with these numbers so you can recognize a fair price – and spot an inflated one. Set your target discount and walk-away price based on real market insights.
• ✅ Pinpoint Contract Clauses to Negotiate: Prepare a list of must-have contract protections you will insist on. This should include the items discussed (audit clause limits, clear digital access terms, shelfware swap rights, maintenance cap, termination flexibility, etc.). Prioritize which terms are deal-breakers versus nice-to-haves. Having this list ready ensures you won’t overlook critical clauses when the draft contract is on the table.
• ✅ Align Stakeholders and Set Escalation Strategy: Internally, align your stakeholders – IT, procurement, legal, and executive sponsors – on the negotiation plan and limits. Decide in advance what approvals are needed for various concessions and who will step in if talks hit a stalemate. For example, know when to involve your CFO or CIO in discussions. Establish walk-away points and an escalation chain if SAP isn’t meeting your requirements. This way, the SAP sales team knows you’re prepared to hold firm (and walk if necessary), which increases your leverage.

By checking off these steps, you’ll enter your S/4HANA licensing negotiation in a position of strength – well-informed, united on priorities, and ready to secure the best possible deal for your organization.

With the right preparation and strategy, you can turn SAP’s sales process into a buyer’s advantage and set the foundation for a successful S/4HANA journey on your terms.

Read about our SAP Advisory Services

Do you want to know more about our SAP Advisory Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit