Negotiating Microsoft Renewal Discounts: How to Avoid the “Loyalty Tax”

Introduction – The “Loyalty Tax” Problem

In the world of Microsoft licensing, long-time customers often encounter the so-called “loyalty tax” at renewal. This isn’t an official fee, but rather the phenomenon where loyal customers face higher renewal prices while new customers are lured with special promos and discounts.

Microsoft might offer a new enterprise a fantastic introductory deal, but if you’ve been a customer for years, your renewal quote could come back higher than before.

In other words, you stay, you pay. It’s an ironic penalty for loyalty that many CIOs and procurement leads find all too familiar. Read our guide to Microsoft Renewal Negotiation: How to Cap Price Uplifts and Secure Discounts.

The good news is that this dynamic can be reversed. You don’t have to accept a loyalty tax as inevitable. By approaching your contract renewal like a fresh negotiation, you can push back against automatic price hikes.

In fact, savvy organizations often secure a Microsoft renewal discount that keeps costs flat or even lower than the previous term. The key is understanding why Microsoft tends to raise prices on renewals – and using proven tactics to flip the script in your favor.

Why Microsoft Often Raises Renewal Prices

When renewal time arrives, Microsoft frequently justifies price increases with various arguments.

They might cite “added value” – for example, new features or products (like bundling in Microsoft 365 Copilot or enhanced security tools) that have been introduced since your last agreement.

Sometimes they point to inflation and market adjustments, claiming that a cost-of-living or currency change means prices must go up.

Microsoft’s sales reps may also imply that list prices have risen for everyone, so your renewal is simply aligning with current rates.

While these explanations sound reasonable, they don’t mean a price hike is unavoidable. Microsoft’s default strategy is often to test the waters at renewal: they assume you’re less likely to switch platforms after years of investment, so they start with a higher quote.

This creates a loyalty tax situation – you pay more just because you’re an existing customer. But here’s the reality: all of these increases are negotiable.

You have every right to push back and ask for a loyalty discount instead of an uplift. Remember that retaining an existing customer is valuable to Microsoft. Long-term clients can (and should) make the case that their years of loyalty and growing usage warrant a better deal, not a penalty.

By challenging the initial renewal quote, you can often avoid those price hikes entirely. The following tactics will show how to do exactly that.

Tactic 1: Treat the Renewal Like a New Deal

One of the most effective strategies is to approach your Microsoft renewal as if you were a brand-new customer.

Don’t treat it as a routine administrative update; treat it like a fresh negotiation for a new contract. This mindset keeps you from getting complacent and signals to Microsoft that you’re willing to walk away if the offer isn’t right.

Start by asking Microsoft for a fresh proposal. Tell your account team you want to see the best pricing and incentives they’d give to win a new customer of your size. Often, vendors reserve their biggest discounts for landing new business; make Microsoft work just as hard to keep your business.

You can even create some competitive pressure by exploring alternatives. Consider running an RFP process or getting quotes from Microsoft partners and resellers. For instance, invite proposals for moving certain workloads to other providers or to a Cloud Solution Provider (CSP) agreement.

Even if you have no immediate plans to switch, showing that you’re evaluating all options puts constructive pressure on Microsoft. It conveys: “We’re not a sure thing – give us a reason to stay.”

By treating the renewal like a new deal to be won, you encourage Microsoft to approach pricing more aggressively, often yielding a significantly better renewal negotiation discount than the initial offer.

Prepare for your renewal. Preparing for a Microsoft Contract Renewal: Timeline & Checklist.

Tactic 2: Cite Your Track Record & Volume

Your long relationship with Microsoft is not a weakness – it’s one of your greatest strengths in negotiation. Make sure Microsoft knows that you expect your loyalty and volume of business to be rewarded, not taken for granted.

This means explicitly citing your track record as leverage for a better price.

Come to the table armed with data on how many years you’ve been a customer, how your spending has grown, and how widely Microsoft’s products are deployed in your organization. For example, you might say: “We’ve been a Microsoft client for 10 years, and our usage has only increased.

To continue this partnership, we’re looking for at least a X% loyalty discount on our renewal.” By framing it this way, you position a discount as a reasonable ask because of your loyalty. You’re effectively saying: reward our consistent business with a better rate. This counters the “you’re already committed” stance that some sales reps take when they assume an existing customer will accept the status quo.

It also reminds Microsoft that you have options – long-term loyalty is a two-way street, and if they don’t reciprocate with fair pricing, that loyalty could waver.

In many cases, when you call out your history and importance as a customer, Microsoft will relent on some of those renewal price increases.

They would rather make concessions than risk losing a large, steady account. Use your scale and loyalty to flip the narrative: instead of a loyalty tax, push for a loyalty rebate in the form of a discounted renewal.

Tactic 3: Lock in Discounts for Multi-Year

Another way to avoid paying more at renewal is to negotiate price protections into a multi-year agreement.

Microsoft Enterprise Agreements typically run for three years, and you have an opportunity to lock in favorable pricing for that entire term and even set the stage for your next renewal’s costs.

The goal is to prevent the scenario where you get a discount in year one, only to give it all back through increases in years two and three (a classic loyalty tax move).

When negotiating, push for multi-year price caps or flat pricing. For example, insist on a clause that caps any yearly price uplift at 0% (or a minimal percentage) during the term. It’s even possible to lock pricing so that you pay the same rate in Year 3 as in Year 1. Microsoft won’t volunteer this, but if you ask – especially as part of a larger commitment – they often agree to some level of price protection.

This ensures that you actually realize the savings of any discount throughout the contract, rather than seeing those savings eroded by later increases. Also, be wary of “promotional” discounts that only apply to the first year of a renewal.

If Microsoft offers, say, 15% off for year one but plans to revert to full price afterward, negotiate that discount to apply across all three years. Consistency is key: lock in the discount for the full term so you’re not hit with a surprise jump in year two.

If you are willing to make a longer commitment, use that as a bargaining chip. Recommitting for a full three-year (or even extending to a five-year) term should come with improved discount tiers or perks. Make it clear: “If we lock in a multi-year renewal, we expect pricing protection and a better rate for that commitment.”

Often, Microsoft will concede to enhanced terms – like an extra few points off or an agreement to limit any future list price changes – in exchange for the certainty of a multi-year deal.

By negotiating hard on these points, you ensure that your renewal delivers true long-term savings, not a short-term teaser followed by a loyalty tax later.

Check out our tips, Avoiding Microsoft Renewal Price Creep: How to Cap Annual Uplifts.

Tactic 4: Bring in Executive Leverage

Sometimes, the fastest way to break a stalemate in negotiations is to elevate the conversation. Bringing your executives into the discussion – and likewise engaging Microsoft’s higher-ups – can create pressure that yields a better offer.

Microsoft’s front-line sales teams have limits on the discounts or terms they can approve. But a CIO or CFO weighing in signals to Microsoft that this deal is a top organizational priority, and it often triggers higher-level attention from Microsoft in return.

There are a couple of ways to use executive leverage. One approach is to have a senior leader (like your CIO) directly communicate your stance to Microsoft’s sales management. For instance, your CIO might join a negotiation meeting or send a message that says, “Current pricing isn’t acceptable – we need a more strategic partnership on this renewal.”

This kind of executive involvement shows Microsoft that your company means business and that the status quo offers won’t fly. It also helps align the conversation with business value rather than just pennies per license – executives talk in terms of the big picture, which can encourage Microsoft to get creative with discounts or add extra value (such as added support or services) to close the deal.

Another aspect is internal escalation planning. Decide in advance how and when you will escalate within your own chain and Microsoft’s. Perhaps your CFO is ready to speak with Microsoft’s regional finance lead or you’re prepared to involve your CEO if talks stall. Knowing that you have that escalation plan in your back pocket can be immensely powerful.

Microsoft’s reps certainly take note when high-level stakeholders are engaged – it often compels them to seek additional approvals or concessions to avoid losing face in front of your leadership.

In practice, we’ve seen that a polite but firm note from a CEO to a Microsoft executive (saying something like “We need Microsoft to work with us on better terms or we’ll explore alternatives”) can swiftly unlock a stalled negotiation.

Use this tactic judiciously: executive time is valuable, but for a major renewal, it can be the difference-maker that pushes Microsoft to eliminate the loyalty tax and give you a true discount.

Loyalty Tax vs. Negotiation Tactics

Below is a comparison of common “loyalty tax” scenarios versus the counter-tactics that can neutralize them in a Microsoft renewal:

(“Shelfware” refers to licenses or products you bought but aren’t using. Removing those ensures you’re not paying for unused capabilities.)

FAQs

• Why does Microsoft raise renewal prices?
  Microsoft often cites factors such as inflation, exchange rates, or added product value to justify price increases at renewal. They also know many customers feel “locked in,” so they test higher pricing. The truth is, these increases are not automatic – they’re an opening gambit. With negotiation, you can frequently avoid or minimize price hikes despite Microsoft’s justifications.
• What is the Microsoft “loyalty tax”?
  The “loyalty tax” is what we call the extra cost existing customers end up paying compared to new customers. Instead of rewarding long-term clients, a vendor might offer better deals to new clients and raise prices on renewals. In Microsoft’s case, it means a loyal EA customer might face a higher per-user price at renewal than a brand-new customer would pay. It’s essentially a penalty for staying with the same provider without pushing back.
• Can I really get a renewal discount?
  Yes – absolutely. Microsoft renewal discounts are attainable if you approach the process strategically. Don’t accept Microsoft’s first quote as final. By treating your renewal like a new deal, benchmarking what other companies pay, and asserting your leverage (usage, loyalty, alternative options), you can negotiate meaningful discounts off the initial price. Many organizations have successfully locked in renewal pricing that is lower than what they paid before.
• What’s the best way to cap price uplifts?
  The best approach is to negotiate written terms in your contract that limit any price increases. For example, include a clause that any year-over-year increase is capped at a small percentage (or zero). You can also negotiate that your existing unit prices remain fixed for the full term. Essentially, get it in writing that Microsoft cannot suddenly raise rates on your licenses during the agreement. This protects you from surprise cost spikes and makes your budgeting predictable.
• Do executives need to be involved?
  Often, yes. In tough negotiations, having your CIO, CFO, or other executives step in can signal to Microsoft that getting a better deal is a top priority for your company. Executive involvement brings authority and can prompt Microsoft to escalate on their side as well – meaning your account might get attention from higher-level decision-makers who have more flexibility to improve the offer. It shows Microsoft you’re serious about not accepting a loyalty tax, which usually results in a more customer-friendly outcome.

Five Expert Recommendations

To wrap up, here are five key takeaways from a Microsoft licensing negotiation expert on avoiding the loyalty tax:

1. Never accept Microsoft’s first renewal quote. It’s almost always a high-anchor starting point. Always counteroffer.
2. Benchmark discounts against new-customer promos. Know what deals newcomers get – it sets a baseline for what you should demand as well.
3. Use your track record and loyalty as leverage. Remind Microsoft of your long partnership and growing spend to justify better pricing.
4. Always cap uplifts and lock in multi-year pricing. Don’t leave future prices to chance – negotiate ceilings on increases and secure discounts for every year of the term.
5. Escalate at the executive level if Microsoft resists. If talks stall, involve senior leadership. High-level pressure can break through vendor roadblocks and get you the deal you deserve.

By following these strategies, you can approach your next Microsoft Enterprise Agreement or contract renewal with confidence.

The goal is to turn the “loyalty tax” on its head – transforming it into a loyalty dividend in the form of better pricing and terms for your organization.

With preparation, a bit of boldness, and a willingness to negotiate hard, even long-standing Microsoft customers can secure renewal deals that rival (or beat) what any new customer would get.

Enjoy the savings – you’ve earned them through your loyalty, and now you know how to negotiate to keep them.

Read about our Advisory Services

Do you want to speak with us about our Microsoft Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit